• home
• back to Back Issues list

Birstall Post May 2006 (274) continued

Breakfast fundraisers

A BIRSTALL couple cooked breakfasts and served afternoon teas to raise money for Cancer Research UK


Pic: Jan Gaskell

Jan and David Gaskell participated in the charity's 'Britain's Biggest Breakfast' campaign by holding a fundraising day at their Roman Road home.
Jan as treasurer for the Charnwood Branch of Cancer Research and her husband David, agreed to be Breakfast Hosts and together with their daughter Jane who travelled from Bicester to help out, cooked a total of 29 'Brunches' between 12noon and 2pm and served 14 Afternoon Teas between 2.30pm and 4pm.
The branch committee members gave their full support for the event by providing homemade cakes for the 'Afternoon Tea' and practical help serving the food, washing up a mountain of plates and cutlery and selling raffle tickets. The event raised £333.50 for the work of Cancer Research UK.


Spanish trip for Longslade students

FORTY DESIGN and technology students from Longslade Community College recently visited the region of Catalonia, Spain to experience some of the cultural heritage the area has to offer.


Pic: Longslade students in Spain

Students visited the Sagrada Familia cathedral, the Olympic village and attended two seminars on the role of design and technology in the marketing and management of Porta Ventura, Universal theme park.
They also visited the Nou Camp stadium, and tried out the away changing rooms days before the Galactico's of Real Madrid used the very same facilities.
Teacher Sandeep Tara said: "It is essential that students are given the opportunity through educational visits to apply what they have learnt in class to a global context. All of our students valued this opportunity and conducted themselves in a manner conducive to the college ethos."
Student Sarah Tanser said: "The best part was visiting the Gaudi Cathedral and realising the scale and amount of effort it must have taken to carve out each individual stone'. Joshua Farrell said: "It was one of the best trips I've been on with school and I was really sad to have to come back'.


Beat Officer’s column

The past 31 days in the village have not passed without incident. There have been five burglary dwellings in the Birstall area, in three of which the residents had left their homes insecure. The police are constantly putting the message out to the public that crime prevention is the best way to tackle criminal behaviour.
To highlight the point, having completed a search on the police system. I have discovered over the past 100 days, there have been 319 burglary dwellings throughout Leicestershire in which the offenders have gained entry through an insecure window or door. I believe this figure shows how important it is for us to secure our properties. Being burgled can be a very traumatic experience for the victim. Victims often feel very vulnerable for a considerable time after their home has been broken into. They will often describe feelings of vulnerability inside their own houses as they know the offenders have been into their home and violated their space. If 319 people had secured their premises there would potentially have been 319 less victims of crime, in less than four months. In several of these burglaries the offenders have taken sets of car keys that had been left downstairs in plain view, and the vehicles were stolen. Always ensure your property is secure and that items such as car keys are not easily accessible near to front or back doors.
There was also an armed robbery at Kingsgate Stores on March 28, 2006. Two suspects armed with handguns entered the store wearing all dark clothing and masks. They threatened persons in the store before stealing the till and assaulting the store worker. The store worker received minor injuries but clearly the incident has shaken those concerned with the store. We believe the incident is isolated and there is no greater risk to businesses within Birstall then there will always be. Enquiries continue but I would urge anybody who may have seen something suspicious (particularly on the Gates estate) to contact us immediately.
Further to the robbery above, the Minimarket on Wanlip Lane near the junction with Lambourne Road has also been subjected to a robbery. On April 16, 2006 one suspect wearing all black and a balaclava entered the store with a knife and threatened staff before making off with the contents of the till. No-one was hurt in the incident and it is believed the suspect may have made off towards Meadow Lane. Again, enquiries continue and I would urge anyone with information that may be beneficial to enquiries to contact us as soon as possible.
There has also been a continuation of anti-social behaviour around Friends in Soggy Homes on Wanlip Lane. Groups of youths are congregating in front of the shops and causing problems for residents and patrons of the amenities there. Whilst understanding that a group of youths on their own may well not be constituting an offence there have been several reports of the youths being verbally abusive to persons passing by. Myself and CSO Mark Butler are aware of the youths' details and look to take the action necessary to prevent such behaviour.
The Neighbourhood Watch in Birstall continues to lead all other Watches in its number of members and its contribution to the community. With a stronghold of 2512 members it has raised over £3000 of donations within the last year. This revenue will all be ploughed back into the community to raise the quality of life.
With more members the Neighbourhood Watch can only get stronger and will continue to provide an excellent service for the residents of Birstall. With strong partnerships with agencies such as the Watch, the police and their partners can only become more effective in combating criminal activity.
If you would like to join, please contact your nearest Neighbourhood Watch Co-ordinator or visit them during the advice shop surgery. This is held on the third Saturday of every month at the Neighbourhood Watch Office on Sibson Road (found at the rear of the car park next to the junction of Sibson Road and Front Street). Wherever possible there will also be a police presence.
If you have any information relating to the incidents above please call 0116 222 2222. Alternatively you can call Crimestoppers on 0800 555111. You can call anonymously with information about criminal activity.
PC826 Jamie Hughes


Trip to Jerusalem

Helping Homeless Children
A small group from St James Church, Birstall recently spent a wonderful 10 days in Israel on a pilgrimage holiday, led by the Rev Sheila Skidmore. During their time there, they visited two homes for orphaned and destitute Palestinian children in Bethany, one of the villages torn apart by the building of the new 'security' wall around the city by the authorities in Jerusalem.


Pic: Palestinian orphans in Jerusalem

These homes were founded by an amazing Christian Palestinian couple, Alice and Basil Sahhar, in the 1970s, as an attempt to rescue some of the Arab children they found on the streets, starting with a group of 10 boys, crammed into a flat. Over the years, the need for their work has grown rather than lessened, so donors have raised money to build a school with a boarding facility for 120 boys. Meanwhile the Sahhar's daughter is running a home for over 30 girls which is in urgent need of expansion.
Thanks to gifts of many people moved by their situation, these children aged from 3 to 18 live now out of danger, but with few of the comforts or opportunities for play which living in even the poorest family in this country might expect. The group from St James would like to do what they can to help, starting with a coffee morning at St James' Church, Church Hill on Saturday May 20 from 10am to12noon. There will be a speaker from the friends of the Lazarus Home for Girls at about 11am and an exhibition of photographs of this and the Jeel Al Amal (Children of Hope) Boys' Home. Please come and support this effort.
Other News from St James and Wanlip
There are various events this month to which all are invited, starting with the family to the Crich Tramway Village on Saturday May 13. Sandra may still have some places available (£8) if you contact her on 2677238. Then, as part of the 80th anniversary celebrations of the Leicester diocese, a touring theatre group is presenting a drama 'which combines excitement and fun, with a serious look at the issues which have faced our communities down the ages'. There will be local performances at Leicester Cathedral on Sunday May 7 at 4pm and Wednesday June 7 at 7.30pm or at all Saints, Loughborough on Friday May 12. Tickets at £3.50 (3 for £10) can be obtained via the Church Office tel: 2671797
Many of our church members, along with Methodists and Catholics, will be involved in collecting for Christian Aid Week from May 14 to 20 so please give generously.
Finally, 'Celebrate 80' will come to a climax on Saturday June 3, with the Big Day Out in Abbey Park for which a bus has been arranged (to avoid parking problems) to pick up from the Village Hall at 11am, returning at 5.30pm (ring church office on 2671797 to book). There is a huge programme of events for the day with a communion service led by the Archbishop of Canterbury as the centrepiece of the afternoon. Purple wristbands, price £1, are on sale at the church as your admission to the day's events.


Corbett’s cricket corner

It has been a busy time for some of the youngsters at the club.


Pic: (l-r) Head Coach Rob Drake, Dips Patel, Russell Cobb, Ben Drake, Yash Thakrar, George Corbett and Max Lewin at a coaching session at Grace Road.

During the winter they have been having trials at Grace Road, the home of Leicestershire County Cricket Club. George Corbett, Yash Thakrar, Ben Drake and Max Lewin are now waiting to hear whether they have done enough to get in the County Under 10 squad. Russell Cobb, Leicestershire excellence coach said: "The lads have all done very well, it is never easy to get into any county squad and they should be proud to have got this far. A final decision will be made after they play on a outdoor pitch next month."


Pic: (l-r) sisters Taylor Findley & Jodie Findley


Pic: Decorating the changing rooms are Rob Drake, Tom Corbett, Tom New, Doug Topley and Andy Corbett


Pic: Some of Birstall Parish Council's Estate Team (l-r) Stuart Clare, Richard Ludlam, David Gee, Graeme Sloman


Pic: Hamish Carnan painting a sightscreen

The club is getting ready for the new season and the groundsman have been very busy getting the pitches in good order. Birstall Parish Council's Estate Team Manager Andy Garland said: "We have been scarifying, cutting and heavy cross rolling the square ready for the start of the season. I am concerned that with the continuing growth and success of the juniors, the surfaces will begin to suffer later on in the season, with an extra 30 matches to be played. As long as the weather stays favourable there should not be a problem".
As part of an English Cricket Board initiative to improve club facilities, the club registered to join 'Cricket Force'. Over 1000 clubs throughout the country have signed up, with only 25 coming from Leicestershire The initiative was held over a weekend in April and the aim was to get the pavilion ready for the new season. It was given a major make-over both inside and out which was carried out by the old faithful at Birstall Village, Steve Findley, Andy Merry, Hamish Carnan, Rob Drake and Doug Topley.. A player from Leicestershire Tom New came to give the Birstall lads a hand.
I would also like to thank some of the younger members of the club who gave up their valuable free time to help and these included Tom Corbett, Ben and Jamie Drake, and Taylor and Jodie Findley.
All we need now is the sun.
From Andy Corbett


Try bowls at open day

BIRSTALL BOWLING Club will be holding an open evening for anyone who is interested in playing bowls.


Pic: Birstall Bowling Club members on the new veranda outside the clubhouse on the opening day of the new season.

This takes place at the club on School Lane Playing Fields on Tuesday May 9 from 6.30-8pm. Everyone is welcome and all you need are a pair of flat shoes or trainers. Club members will be on hand to offer advice and assistance if required.
The new season started last month and the club have welcomed several new members already. Over 40 members were at the club on the opening day of the season and visitors to the club this year will be able to view the changes made during the winter. These include a new veranda, which gives access for disabled visitors, double glazed windows that will enhance the view from inside the clubhouse, a new kit store and general refurbishment including painting and decorating.
For more information about the club, men can call Grahame on 2677994 or Andy on 2677100, while ladies can contact Jan on 2122578 or Diane on 2675457. You can also visit the new Birstall Bowling club website, the address is: http://beehive.thisisleicestershire.co.uk/birstallbowlingclub or go to Google and search for 'Birstall Bowling Club'.


Your Say...

The short answer to Cllr Edwards comments concerning Regional Government Bodies (RGB's) is that they have been created by this government and specifically by dear old Two Jags (or is that three now) himself, John Prescott.
Having been given the non-job of Deputy PM, he had to find something to do and set about creating his own sprawling empire along old fashioned socialist principles which include a top heavy bureaucratic administration. Secondly, and probably more worryingly, these useless levels of repetitive and needless government are there to fulfil the wishes of our overlords in Brussels who would see every country in Europe lose their national identity to become one polyglot divided into arbitrary administrative areas, all reporting back to some unelected faceless body within the EU.
The same process is happening to the Police force, and also shows up in the almost terminal amount of money wasted in the NHS on countless levels of management all checking on and repeating the work of the level below them. This is classical Stalinism at work, and produces the same poor results.
They should be scrapped immediately.
Nicholas G Black

Charnwood claim that they do not know the location of a further development which is planned north of Birstall. The logical location is NW Wanlip. Could the planners inform us of alternative locations? The planners say that the new development would balance Hallam Fields. What location would balance Hallam Fields? The developers have taken SW Wanlip and joined it to Birstall. If the planers do take NW Wanlip, then central Wanlip will be the next to be developed. Why not rename the whole area? All this development will bring more traffic through Birstall.
The Thurmaston County Councillor thinks the location is ideal and that leaves Birstall and Rothley the only local people interested. Why can't we see a complete finished plan of Hallam Fields with all the alterations?
On an earlier map there were two roundabouts on the A6 for access/exit to Hallam Fields. Two roundabouts are wanted now. The speed limit of 40mph must be extended up to the A6/A46 junction now, with better and bigger signs. A 1,000 Park & Ride must be adjacent to the A6/A46 junction or some of the playing fields will disappear. If more traffic comes through Birstall, more motorists will try the very dangerous Bentley Rd manoeuvre.
If Birstall is industrialised can someone name a local hero/heroine. Many years ago I parked my minibus some 20 metres from the statue of Joseph Priestly (Birstall, Yorkshire)
Les Briers

I am writing regarding an incident which happed for the second time on School Lane playing fields.
On a Tuesday afternoon whilst out with my dog and 4yr old son who was learning to ride his bike. Our afternoon was soon to be spoilt for the second time. We were enjoying a practice session and were doing well (no falling off!) and keen to start off on his own steam. When a white and black female collie came over and attacked my dog. My dog was on the lead and was being dragged by her tail from me. The owner, a young girl of approx 15 yrs, was not in sight at the time. When she did come to get her dog I said to her that's the second time your dog has done that. She replied in an abusive and aggressive manner which my little boy had to witness. Not once did she apologise and not once did she stop to think about my boy or any other children onlooking. It all makes you want to give up on today's youth and would have if it wasn't for another teenager who stopped what he was doing and asked if my dog was OK. She wasn't, she suffered grazing and bruising but I replied by thanking him for asking.
It wasn't so long ago that I was a youth but I would never have dared to swear and challenge my elders and I will certainly drum it in to my boy that her behaviour was very, very wrong!
Hayley Kennington

May I thank everyone who helped in so many ways when the Birstall Methodist Church recently held a Village Auction? £824 was raised toward the ongoing expenses of the church and a special thanks is expressed to all who donated gifts for the auction and to those who helped with the sale on the day.
John Kilby

Allow me through your columns to thank all those people who have taken the trouble to contact Holly Hayes with records for the local frog and toad survey I mis-organised, and to apologise to the staff of Holly Hayes who have been swamped by the number of calls they have received. Whilst I do not know the exact figures I understand from the staff that they have had to ask people to fill out 'Pondomania' forms and post them back. I must apologise, therefore, to people who have been further inconvenienced.
For many people it appears that Holly Hayes provides a spawn removal service; I have been asked to point out to those people that this is not the case. Whilst it is not against the law to remove frog spawn from your pond, nobody involved in this survey will do it for you. I have also been asked to point out that the Pondomania forms contains a statement that they do not apply to gardens. These are old forms from a previous county-wide survey, and have not been corrected for our little local one.
When I started this survey I had a verbal agreement with both Holly Hayes and with the Birstall Post that they would collect records for me. I did this deliberately, for large organisations are less likely to invade the privacy of people who do not want any 'follow-ups'. I also gave them to understand that I did not expect a large response as I had vastly underestimated the number of ponds with frogs in Birstall. I was wrong.
From the bluebell/ragged robin survey the Parish Council have agreed to accept written records through their letter box. Please note that they will not accept telephone calls. For this survey we just need your location and the type of flower.
For any future botanical surveys is there a Birstall gardening club out there who could help? Are there any keen botanists? If so, please give the Post a call and they will pass a message on to me.
Dr D A C McNeil (Assistant Heritage Warden)

I wish to thank Borough Councillor Helena Edwards for her letter in the Birstall Post of April responding to my query about "regional government bodies".
I think her answer was long but certainly not dull. It was very informative but also quite alarming.
Basically it appears that we have now in the East Midlands three government bodies which are able to override decisions taken at County Council level. They are the Government Office for the East Midlands (GOEM) with 282 staff, the East Midlands Regional Assembly (EMRA) with 20 staff and the East Midlands Development Agency (EMDA) with 220 staff. That is a total of 522 staff, probably increasing all the time. If we take the average wage of those 522 to be say £15,000 - probably a low estimated average as several staff will be getting (but not necessarily earning) much more than that. That gives a figure of £7,830,000. Then there are all the other costs of running the buildings; heating and lighting etc, plus all the expenses paid to the delegates and representatives who attend the meetings of EMRA. Therefore we are looking no doubt at an annual cost of at least £10million in running these three bodies. When the system of local government ie Parish Councils, Town Councils, City Councils, Borough Councils and County Councils has been in existence for centuries and has served the population well, why do we need to tinker with it? And indeed to probably do away with a lot of the present system: for as Helena Edwards states: "We will be losing either Borough and District councils or County ones by 2008". I don't remember such drastic local government changes being proposed in general election manifestos. I remember before the 1997 general election being told by New Labour that we had 48 hours to save the NHS - what a sick joke that has become - but I don't remember being told that GOEMs, Regional Assemblies and Development Agencies were to be set up. In fact I had the impression that Regional Assemblies were not going to be set up in a region unless a majority of electors voted for this to happen. The people in the North East of England were allowed to vote last year on whether there should be a Regional Assembly in that area and they voted against such a proposal. However it seems that the Government may be about to disregard that vote and to bring about an Assembly by stealth: a letter published recently in a national newspaper from a person living in the North East stated that he had seen an advert for an administrative post in the North East Regional Assembly! We seem to have entered a period where a democratically elected government is behaving like a dictatorship.
J Woods


Monster putt wins match

AN EXTRA time win over Cosby saw Birstall Gold Club reach the third round of the Mail on Sunday National Golf Club Classic.


Pic: Graham Marshall watching Steve Sansome on the 17th

The Club reached the finals of this competition in 2004, held in Spain.
They edged out a Cosby team including Steve Sansome, who until last season played for Birstall, when Graham Marshall holed an 18 foot putt for birdie at the second extra hole and saw former colleague Sansome's attempt to match it from around a third of that distance slip by the hole.
With the match tied at 2-2, and wins for Scott Wormleighton and Chris Webb off-setting losses for Richard Reed and Stuart Marriott, Sansome was one up and had put his drive safely on the front of the green at the par three 17th. Marshall's response was a drive finishing barely 18 inches away from the hole for a winning birdie that took the match down the par five 18th all square.
He had to survive another scare there, when he put his approach through the green with Sansome safely on and below the hole. But a chip and putt secured a half and took the match into extra holes, the first of which was halved in par.
Earlier Marshall had gone two up after eight holes before both men scored birdie threes to halve the 9th. Playing off scratch, he won the 14th to go one up courtesy of the shot he received of Sansome (off plus one) - the "first shot I've received for years!" - although he then lost the 15th and 16th to set up the tense finish.
Earlier Scott Wormleighton won 4 and 3, taking control of his match against Adam Dalby by winning the 3rd, 5th, 6th and 7th holes, the last two with birdies, after driving out of bounds to lose the first.
Stuart Marriott was never ahead against David Gibson and went down two and one, while Richard Reed lost 3 and 2 against Liam Plant, but Chris Webb won the first, 5th and 6th on the way to overcoming Mike Manship 2 and 1.
After the Cosby match Playing Captain Stuart Marriott commented: "All the players who went to Spain really enjoyed the experience and we'd love to get there again. There's a long way to go, but we've shown terrific fighting spirit in these first two rounds and played some exceptional golf. Graham's nerve under pressure is extraordinary. We're really looking forward to see who we get in the next round".


African adventure

A GROUP of teenagers from Longslade visited hospitals and schools in the Gambia to study the health system of a developing country at first hand.
The Health and Social Care and Psychology A-level students had raised nearly £9,000 from sponsorship and fundraising to pay for their trip, which was led by Longslade's Head of Social Sciences, Kim Philpot.
While in the Gambia they visited a hospital, a health care clinic, an orphanage and two schools. Kim said: "We made donations to all of these from the money we had raised and it is fantastic to know that there is a school in Africa which has new classroom furniture because of the Longslade students. We are hoping to further develop the links we have made in the future."
Other highlights of the trip included watching the sunrise from dug out canoes on the River Gambia, a camel ride, dolphin watching and taking part in the country's independence day celebrations.


Methodist Church news

Is it the Oldest Boiler in Birstall?
It is thought that the boiler that heats the premises is probably one of the oldest in the village. One estimate is that it has faithfully heated our building for 43 years. However this winter it has shown signs of its age and has let us down on a few occasions. Coupled with the fact it is not that efficient in the use of gas, spare parts are very difficult to get, the decision has been reached that it needs to be replaced. Hopefully the work can be completed during the summer. The inevitable question which arises as to where the money will come from does need to be addressed.

Going going GONE
Well most of it went anyway! There were a few items our auctioneers couldn't get a bid for, but at the end of the day, with lunches and teas, and an 'April' stall, the end result was £824 from the Auction on April 1. This money was all for church funds.

Tsunami Relief Coffee Morning
The church supported some families in Sri-Lanka last year, and we gather those families are at last having rather basic houses built. These families still need our support, they lost everything in the Tsunami. Funds will help them furnish their replacement houses. All our Saturday coffee mornings are in aid of one good cause or another. The coffee morning for this appeal is on Saturday May 13.

Wednesday Volunteer Needed
Can you help one Wednesday, every six weeks? A further helper is needed to join the team that prepare and serve meals at our Luncheon Club for elderly and lonely people in Birstall. Contact Sheila Wilson if you can help. Tel: 2675973


League winners

BIRSTALL UNITED Under 9 Foxes have captured the Division 7 League title in some style, having gone undefeated in all of their games.



They have racked up 40 points and 66 goals along the way, only conceding 11. They won the league by 11 clear points. They are pictured with the League trophy.


Age Concern info

What was in the Budget for Pensioners
o Free nationwide off-peak bus travel for people aged 60 and over - from April 2008.
o The inheritance tax threshold will rise from £275,000 to £325,000 but it will not reach that figure until four years' time - in April 2010
o The threshold for paying stamp duty on property purchases has increased from £120,000 to £125,000 - not a rise to shout about and it won't affect many pensioners unless they are downsizing to a much smaller house.
o The £200 given to the elderly last year before the general election to help them meet rising council tax bills has not been continued. Pensioner groups are outraged by this.
o Changes to family trusts mean that parents and grandparents can no longer tie up money passed down in a trust until their heirs are aged 25, as they have been able to do hitherto. Instead they must either give children or grandchildren access to assets at the age of 18 or pay a 20% tax levy when setting up a trust, plus an additional 6% tax on the trust's value every 10 years and a further 6% when assets come out of the trust. As one solicitor has commented: "It is crazy to say people have got to set up trusts so their children get their hands on the money just when they are going to university and when they are still young and vulnerable. Thousands of people are now going to have to look at their wills and trusts and consider redrafting them."
Gordon Lishman, the executive director of Age Concern England has stated: "It beggars belief that the Chancellor has denied pensioners any extra help with their council tax bills, just as a new round of bills is set to cause anxiety for millions. More needs to be done to help older people meet the huge hikes in energy bills. Spiralling household costs are causing widespread anxiety."
I personally feel very disappointed that the Chancellor has done nothing after nine years to make the tax and the benefits system simpler. It is now so complicated that even financial experts have to make very careful examination of all the rules and regulations to b able to advise people correctly. The complexity of the benefits system deters many people from making claims and many thousands of people entitled to a benefit are losing out and millions of pounds are left unclaimed. It is really a tragedy.

Carers UK: Reports on Poverty and Caring, and New Guides
What I stated in March needs to be repeated:- Carers UK has published a report on caring and poverty which estimates that carers are missing out on an estimated £746 million in unclaimed benefits. Older carers are particularly hard hit, with some 125,000 carers over the age of 60 missing out on Pension Credit and 64,000 losing out on the extra support available through the Carer Addition. The report makes a number of recommendations, including ensuring carers are able to juggle work and care; a reduction in the complexity of claiming carers' benefits; and more flexible services.
Carers UK has produced two guides covering carers' rights and benefits and services for people aged 60 and over :
Carers Rights Guide 15pp and Looking After Someone - A Guide to Benefits and Services for People over 60. 27pp. Both guides available free from : Carers UK, 20-25 Glasshouse Yard, London EC1A 4JT. Also available on the Internet at www.carersuk.org/Newsandcampaigns/CarersrightsDey/Adviceleafletsforcarers.
Information about benefits is also obtainable from Age Concern Leicestershire and Rutland by calling their freephone helpline number on 0800 00 99 66.

Mobility Information
The British Healthcare Trades Association (BHTA) has produced a leaflet for wheelchair users to help them make sure that their wheelchair (whether powered or manual) remains stable in all situations. The leaflet covers information on ramps and slopes, kerbs, steps and soft ground as well as advice on maintenance and weather conditions.
Get Wise : How to Make sure Your Wheelchair Remains Stable 4pp. Available on receipt of a (9"x6") sae from BHTA, Suite 4.06, New Loom House, 101 Back Church Lane, London E1 1LU Tel: 020 7702 2141

Continuing NHS Health Care - Information Guide, Research and Panorama Website Information
Age Concern, Alzheimer's Society, Help the Aged and the Royal College of Nursing have jointly produced a guide to help those in need of care and their carers and professionals working in health and social care, to know when the NHS is responsible for paying for the full package of care, whether at home or in care homes. It explains both the Coughlan and Grogan judgements and how the RNCC bands are assessed. It contains a template of a letter for individuals to use if they wish to challenge the decision that the person is not eligible for fully funded NHS care. It asks for details of any action the local authority may have taken in the light of the Grogan case.
A Panorama Programme shown on March 5, 2006 commissioned research by health and social care analyst Melanie Henwood to establish how many people may have sold their property unnecessarily to pay for care, when the care should have been provided by the NHS. It looks at previous data on numbers of people reported to have sold their homes to pay for care, and the difficulties in establishing data. Taking all the data available, the research estimates that the number of homes sold each year to pay for care is somewhere in the region of 40,000. It then goes on to discuss how many of these have been sold unnecessarily because the person should have been funded by the NHS. Even the number of cases that have been reviewed as a result of the Ombudsman report may be an underestimate, as it is not known if all the cases that should have been reviewed have actually been reviewed, or whether some cases have been overlooked. The range of scenarios suggest somewhere between 120 and 640 people could be involved each year, but this figure could run into thousands rather than hundreds if the criteria being used across the 28 SHAs are not compliant with the law. The research concludes that a significant minority of people entering long term care 'experience a major injustice in being wrongly denied fully funded care and present a challenge that must be addressed by further guidance and the forthcoming national framework for continuing care criteria'.
Following the Panorama programme a number of documents have been posted on the BBC website, including an explanation of the Grogan case by Anne Sprowart, the solicitor who took the case; a historical overview of the continuing care debate by Luke Clements; and comments by the PCTs involved in the cases discussed in the programme.
NHS Continuing Health Care, Action Following the Grogan Judgement 9pp. Available on the Internet at www.dh.gov.uk/assetRoot/04/13/11/64/04131164.pdf
Guide to Fully Funded NHS Care.12pp. Available on the websites of Age Concern, Alzheimer's Society, Help the Aged and the Royal College of Nursing. See www.ageconcern.org.uk/AgeConcern/Documents/Guide_to_fully_funded_NHS_care.pdf
Self-funding of Long-term Care and Potential for Injustice, by Melanie Henwood Associates. 12pp. Available on the Internet at http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/shared/bsp/hi/pdfs/05_03_06_melaniehenwood.pdf
The NHS Continuing Care Responsibilities. 10pp and An Expert's View, 5pp, both by Luke Clements; The Grogan Case by Anne Sprowart, 2pp, and other background information are all available on the Internet at http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/programmes/panorama/4758750.stm

Older Voters : Research Report
Age Concern has published a report on older voters based on two sets of research, from Opinion Leader Research and Loughborough University.
The research found that older voters (ie aged 50+) in England and Wales cast more than 40% of all votes in the last general election and will probably account for nearly half of all votes in England in 2009. Older voters are more likely to vote but also more likely to switch their allegiance than younger voters. They feel that none of the parties understands the problems facing Britain or cares about the issues that matter to them. They are looking for strong local and national leadership and clear policies.
Older voters are concerned about national and personal insecurity, in particular issues of economic stability, taxation and public services, Council Tax, pensions, health and social care, crime and public safety.
The report aims to highlight the importance of the influence older voters have, and warns politicians that no party currently provides what they are looking for. It lists a number of questions that politicians need to be able to answer.
Winning in 2009: the Importance of the Baby Boomers. 26pp. Available on receipt of a (12"x9") sae from Hannah Pearce, Public Affairs Department, Age Concern England. Also available on the Internet at www.20millionvotes.org.uk/report_introduction.html
Jex Woods


• home
• back to Back Issues list